Repost test -- moving my site, want to make sure we're still 'live'...
_____________
Update: boingboing has more background on the MS China blogger story...
Scoble gets hushed, a bit...
__________
Robert Scoble (for those of you who don't know, Microsoft's preeminent blogger) calls his employer out over its censorship of a Chinese blogger;
Guys over at MSN: sorry, I don’t agree with your being used as a state-run thug.
In keeping with my channeling Battelle's book on Google, here's an excerpt from John's book about the fine line Google's walking in China:
...should Google decide to capitulate in China, such a move could lead to charges that the company has done the same in any number of other places. "What may be most important is not the single concessionary act to China, but the precedent that this act would set for Google, namely, that the level of censorship before entry in specific markets will be negotiated on a case-by-case basis," Schell (a China scholar and dean of the Graduate School of Journalism at the University of California, Berkeley) says.
The reality is that you cannot do a content-oriented business involving China without capitulating to censorship. As William Falk observed this weekend in the New York Times;
FORBIDDEN IDEAS With more than 100 million users, the Internet is booming in China. The American Web giants Microsoft, Yahoo and Google have all grabbed a piece of the lucrative Chinese market - but only after agreeing to help the government censor speech on the Web. In providing portals or search engines, all three companies are abiding by the government's censorship of certain ideas and keywords, like "Tiananmen massacre," "Taiwanese independence," "corruption" and "democracy." Most foreign news sites are blocked. This year, Yahoo even supplied information that helped the government track and convict a political dissident who sent an e-mail message with forbidden thoughts from a Yahoo account; he was sentenced to 10 years in jail. "Business is business," said Jack Ma, Yahoo's chief in China. "It's not politics."
What level of 'do no evil' is appropriate in considering the Chinese market?